--

3 (1) 2013

Adopting Japanese lean practices into the Vietnamese context: Slow and steady is the sure way to go


Author - Affiliation:
Reynold James - Phd. MBA, Academic Staff, Swinburne University of Technology
Dinh Nhu Anh - Hoa Sen University , Vietnam
Corresponding author: Reynold James - kim.npt@ou.edu.vn

Abstract
In tandem with Vietnam’s growing economic activity in recent years is the observable trend of Vietnamese firms across various sectors increasingly adopting Japanese lean management principles and practices. Evidencing this is the ever increasing extent of lean related activity in the form of lean management and production workshops, seminars, and training and consulting activity across the nation, with the year 2013 –christened by some- as the ‘year of the lean concepts’. Whilst lean has its advantages, and with a coterie of scholars advocating that lean is an epoch making model, transferable like a technical object from any one geographic location into another and is devoid of context, there are others who advocate that the efficacy of lean –when transplanted outside of Japan- is contingent upon several contextual factors within the host nation. The extant literature on lean and on institutional transplantation reveals several cases wherein attempts to transplant the lean model into non-Japanese socio-cultural climes have resulted in outcomes ranging from minimal success to failure. This paper highlights a few contextual aspects that merit consideration by Vietnamese industries adopting lean practices, and in so doing, purports to tone down any unrealistic perceptions that managers and industrialists may harbor, about lean being a silver bullet that can overnight transform their firms into star performers.

Keywords
lean; transplantation; Toyota Production System (TPS); Kaizen

Full Text:
PDF

References

Abo, T. (1994), Hybrid factory: the Japanese production system in the United States, Oxford University Press: New York


Phan Chi Anh, Zeng Jing & Yoshiki Matsui (2011).Empirical Study on Transferability of Kaizen Practices. The 11th International DSI and the 16th APDSI Joint Meeting, Taipei, Taiwan, July 12 – 16, 2011


Berggren, C (1994), “NUMMI versus Uddevalla”, Sloan Management Review, 35/2: 37-45


Besser, T. L. (1996), Team Toyota: Transplanting the Toyota culture to the Camry plant in Kentucky, State University of New York Press: New York


Becker-Ritterspach, F (2009), Hybridization of MNE subsidiaries: the automotive sector in India, Palgrave-Macmillan: Basingstoke


Cooney, R and Sewell, G (2000), “Lean downunder: reflections on the implementation of an epoch-making model in Australia”, International Workshop, University of Calabria, Rende (Italy)


Florida, R and Kenney, M (1991), “Organisation versus culture: Japanese automotive transplants in the US”, Industrial Relations Journal, 22/3: 181-196


Forrester, R (1995), “Implications of lean manufacturing for human resource strategy”, Work Study, 44/3: 20–24


Gough, R.,& Fastenau, M.(2003) Implementing different concepts of lean production: Workers’ experience of lean production in North American transplants.Working Paper Series, Victoria University, School of Management.


Gupta, S (2008), “Indian and Japanese HRM practices: similarities and differences with analysis of automobile sector in India”, retrieved 3 June 2009 from http://www.aimaind.org/ejournal/articlesPDF/Shruti_Gupta_692320081433269.pdf


Gutterman, A.S. (n.d) ‘ Vietnamese Management Systems Retrieved on 02 April 2013 from http://alangutterman.typepad.com/files/mdc_05.23.2011_vietnamese-management-systems.pdf


Hofstede , G.(2011) ‘The Hofstede Centre ‘ Retrieved on 04 April 2013 from (http://geert-hofstede.com/countries.html)


Holsti, O.R. (1969). Content Analysis for the Social Sciences and Humanities. Reading,MA: Addison-Wesley.


Jain, H (1987), “The Japanese system of human resource management: transferability to the Indian industrial environment”, Asian Survey, 27/9: 1023-1035


James, R. (2011) ‘Transferring the Toyota Production System into India: Seeking Contextual Congruence’. Second Indian Academy of Management (IAM) Conference ,Indian Institute of Management( Bangalore),18th-20 th December 2011


James, R, Mathew, S, and Jones, R (2011a), “Toyota production system in India: a case study”, 9th International Academy of Business and Management Conference, Orlando, Florida.


Jean-Claude Usunier (1996, cited in Kohl, K.S. (Fall 2007).Americans doing business in Vietnam. Retrieved on 03 April 2013 from: www.baruch.cuny.edu/wsas/student_work/documents/Kohl.pdf


Jones, R. and Liu, L (2005), “Embedding TPS within the Australian culture”, presented at the European Academy of Management, Munich


Karlsson, C. and Ahlstron, P (1996), “Assessing changes towards lean production”, International Journal of Operations and Production Management, 16/2: 24-41


Krippendorff, K. (1980). Content Analysis: An Introduction to Its Methodology. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.


Liker, J and Hoseus, M. (2010), “Human resource development in Toyota culture”, International Journal of Human Resources Development and Management, 10/1: 34–50


Liker, J, Fruin, W, and Adler, P (1999), Remade in America: transplanting and transforming Japanese management systems, Oxford University Press: Oxford


Linge, G. J. (1991). “Just-in-Time: More or Less Flexible?” Economic Geography 67 (4) :316-332.


Nguyen, N., Takanashi , C., and Aoyama ,A. (2012), Can Efficient Technology Transfer Be Achieved through a Hybrid Corporate Culture? A Study on Japanese Manufacturing Subsidiaries in Vietnam


Ohno, T (1988), Toyota production system: beyond large-scale production, Productivity Press: New York


Oliver, N, Delbridge, R, and Lowe, J (1996), “Lean production practices: international comparisons in the auto components industry”, British Journal of Management, Special Issue, 7: S29–S44


Pardi, T (2005), “Where did it go wrong? Hybridisation and crisis of Toyota Motor Manufacturing UK, 1989–2001”, International Sociology, 20/1: 93-118


Parker, M. and Slaughter, J (1994), “Lean production is mean production” Canadian Dimension, 28/1: 21-22


Pil, F. K. and MacDuffie, J.P. (1999a), “What makes transplants thrive: managing the transfer of best practice at Japanese auto plants in North America “, Journal of World Business, 34/4: 372-391


Preece, D and Jones, R (2010), “Human resource development and management in lean production”, International Journal of Human Resource Development and Management, 10/1: 1-13


Phan Chi Anh and Nguyen Dang Minh( 2012) Japanese Continuous Improvement Practices Implementation in Vietnamese Manufacturing Companies International Conference : Sustainable Manufacturing and Environment Management Quang, T and Vuong, N. (2002) “Management Styles and Organisational Effectiveness in Vietnam”. Research and Practice in Human Resource Management”, 10(2), 36-55.


Robbins, S (1996), Organizational behaviour, Englewoods Cliffs, NJ


Schutt, R. K.,(2006) Investigating the Social World, 5th ed, Pine Forge Press


Selfridge, R., Sokolik, S. (1975) “A comprehensive view of organizational management”. MSU Business Topics, 23(1), 46-61


Sugimore, Y, Kusunoki, K, Cho, F, and Uchikawa, S (1977), “Toyota production system and kanban system: materialisation of just-in-time and respect-for-human system”, International Journal of Production Research, 15/6: 553-564


Vietnamica (2012).Retrieved on 01 April 2013 from : www.vietnamica.net/vietnams-national-culture-scores-by-geert-hofstede


Wertz, F J, Charmaz, K, McMullen, L M, Josselson, R, Anderson, R, and McSpadden, E (2011), Five ways of doing qualitative analysis, Guildford Press: New York.


Westney, D (1999), “Organization theory perspectives on the cross-border transfer of organizational patterns”, in Liker, J, Fruin, W, and Adler, P (eds), Remade in America: transplanting and transforming Japanese management systems, Oxford University Press: New York, 385-408


Wilms, W, Hardcastle, A. J, and Zell, D.M (1994), “Cultural transformation at NUMMI”, Sloan Management Review, 36/1: 99-113


Womack, J. P, Jones, D. T, and Roos, D (1990), The machine that changed the world, Macmillan: New York


Womack, J P and Jones, D T (1996), Lean thinking: banish waste and create wealth in your corporation, Simon and Schuster: New York


Worley, J. M. and Doolen, T.L (2006), “The role of communication and management support in a lean manufacturing implementation”, Management Decision, 44/2: 228-245


Yokozawa, K, Steenhuis, H, and de Bruijn, E. J (2010), The influence of national culture on Kaizen transfer: An exploratory study of Japanese subsidiaries in the Netherlands, paper presented at the 15th Cambridge International Manufacturing Symposium, Cambridge, UK.



Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.